[R1ch]

Fiat Panda 1st place, VW up 2nd place in their latest review (issue out today).

Am I missing something? I'm sure the Panda is a fine car but 1st place? The interiour looks awful to me - personal taste maybe.

I am sure that I would not trade my up (due soon) for a Panda.

Good article about a 4x4 Lamborghini though

 

[FreyaMx]

I can't understand either how the Fiat Panda has managed 1st over the up, I just can't see what is better?....

 

[Ashy87]

I'd like to see a similar review after 12 months of everyday use with both and see which is better condition, I'm pretty sure the VW will prevail over any Fiat for longevity!

 

[Vdoug]

I recon that some times it just comes down to personal bias of the reviewer, I know if I was reviewing a car I would probably be slightly biased to VW since I have always owner VW cars and for me they are very tried and tested!

 

[funkdubious]

FIAT = Fix It Again Tomorrow!

 

[Paul Childs]

Ha ha, nice one. There are loads like that

SAAB - sad and awfully boring

HONDA - had one never drive again

LOTUS - loads of trouble usually serious

FORD - found on road dead

UP! - understated perfection ???

 

[willowaz]

Ha ha, nice one. There are loads like that

SAAB - sad and awfully boring

HONDA - had one never drive again

LOTUS - loads of trouble usually serious

FORD - found on road dead

UP! - understated perfection ???

brilliant... i love it!

agree with everyone else tho, its very much bias, if you read the review in top gear mag, james may basically freely admits that he is bias towards the panda and thats the reason he wud chose one over the up, and the only reason

 

[TwoUp]

Panda, pah! Up the up!

 

[Mumski1]

Maybe its because we are all waiting and by the time we flood the roads there will be NO CONTEST